Buffalo Nickels (1913-1938)
Home| My Account| Register| Layaways| View Cart| FAQ's| About Us| Contact Us
Collectors Online:  23
 

SEARCH

WHAT ARE YOU LOOKING FOR?


(Enter keyword OR item number)
 

SELECT CATEGORY TO SEARCH:



CATEGORIES

DAILY DEALS!

SPECIAL DEALS THAT CAN EXPIRE AT ANYTIME!!
CLICK HERE TO SEE TODAY'S DEALS!

COINS GALORE!

OUR MOST POPULAR SPECIAL!


CLICK HERE FOR MORE INFORMATION!

LIVE HELP


Live chat is open during our regular phone hours of 9am - 4:30pm MST Monday thru Friday

JOIN THE COMMUNITY!

Home »NICKELS»BUFFALO NICKELS (1913-1938)

BUFFALO NICKELS (1913-1938)

BUFFALO NICKELS (1913-1938)

Buffalo Nickels (1913-1938): In 1913, the “Buffalo” or “Indian Head” Nickel was introduced. This new design features the head of an Indian Chief on the obverse and an American bison on the reverse. The earliest versions (Type 1) had the words “FIVE CENTS” on a raised mound at the base of the reverse. Mint officials feared that the words would wear off the coin too easily, so the later versions (Type 2) of the 1913 Nickel have the words “Five Cents” in a recessed area. Key dates in the series include 1913-S Type 2, 1918/7-D overdate and the 1937-D “Three Legged Buffalo".
 
Page 1 of 1
Sort By:                           Printable View
$20 Surprise Bag of Coins
Item #109350
 
  $20 Surprise Bag of Coins
We have thousands of low priced coins in the $0.25 to $1.50 range that we simply do not have time to list and sell individually. In our Surprise Bag of Coins, we give you a MINIMUM of 20 different coins at a BIG discount. Most of the coins in this group are smaller denominations, such as Indian Cents, Lincoln Cents, Liberty Nickels, Buffalo Nickels, Mercury Dimes and Washington Quarters. Each coin is heavily discounted well below retail, and the bargain price is marked on each coin! This is very similar to our very popular Coins Galore lot, except all coins are $1.50 and lower. These surprise bags are great deals on lower value coins, and you never know what you will get! If you are looking for a super bargain on low value coins, or just want an inexpensive surprise group of coins to add to your order, you can't go wrong with our Surprise Bag of Coins!
$20.00


Availability: 2 in stock
1913 T-1 Buffalo Nickel XF40
Item #110007
  1913 T-1 Buffalo Nickel XF40
Original with a bold horn
$17.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1913 T-2 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #108807
  1913 T-2 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Gorgeous, rich gold toned luster with a bold strike and beautiful eye appeal!
$249.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1913-D T-1 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #108357
1913-D T-1 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Nice and original with deep, golden gray toning on both sides with very subtle luster peeking through the toning
$245.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1913-D T-1 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #109658
  1913-D T-1 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Beautiful, full golden gray luster with a sharp strike and nice eye appeal
$245.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1913-D T-2 Buffalo Nickel AU55 ANACS
Item #109333
  1913-D T-2 Buffalo Nickel AU55 ANACS
Deep, original gold toned luster with more of an AU50 look. A scarce date housed in the original, small ANACS holder
$205.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1913-D T-2 Buffalo Nickel G4 ANACS
Item #99886
1913-D T-2 Buffalo Nickel G4 ANACS
This key date Buffalo has pleasing color with a slightly weak but fully readable date, bold mintmark and the very base of the horn visible.
$99.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1913-D T-2 Buffalo Nickel G6 NGC
Item #103011
1913-D T-2 Buffalo Nickel G6 NGC
Pleasing light silvery gray color on this scarce key date. Shows G6 detail overall, though the date is weak with only partial digits visible, so the price is discounted!
$105.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1913-D T-2 Buffalo Nickel VF30 ANACS
Item #109106
  1913-D T-2 Buffalo Nickel VF30 ANACS
A scarce semi-key date with pleasing original surfaces and a full horn. Housed in the original, small ANACS holder
$149.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1913-D T-2 Buffalo Nickel VG8
Item #101831
1913-D T-2 Buffalo Nickel VG8
This scarce coin has a readable date with some softness on the '19' and about 1/3 of the horn visible!
$135.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1914 Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Item #108834
  1914 Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
A scarcer early date with gorgeous, even gold toned luster and a very bold strike including a split tail
$139.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1914 Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Item #110535
  1914 Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Boldly struck with impressive even gold toned luster
$139.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1914 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #107709
 
1914 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Gorgeous, even champagne gold luster with a bold strike and impressive mark-free surfaces! A scarce, early date that is tough to find in this grade!
$395.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1914-D Buffalo Nickel AU50
Item #110456
  1914-D Buffalo Nickel AU50
Lovely rich, gold toned surfaces with subtle luster and pretty colorful toning in parts of the fields! No problems other than a very minor obverse rim tick mentioned for accuracy
$245.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1914-D Buffalo Nickel AU50 NGC
Item #105257
1914-D Buffalo Nickel AU50 NGC
Pleasing light silvery gray color with some luster remaining and no problems. A scarce, semi-key date!
$275.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1914-D Buffalo Nickel AU50 PCGS
Item #109533
  1914-D Buffalo Nickel AU50 PCGS
Attractive light gray color with a bold horn and nice surfaces. This scarce date is usually seen in AG-VG grades, and is tough to get in this nice collector grade!
$259.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1914-D Buffalo Nickel AU55 NGC
Item #96184
 
1914-D Buffalo Nickel AU55 NGC
Light silvery gray color with a little darker area to the right of the Indian's forehead. Sharp detail with original surfaces and just traces of luster. A scarce date that is tough to find this nice!
$275.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1914-D Buffalo Nickel AU55 NGC
Item #104905
1914-D Buffalo Nickel AU55 NGC
A scarce date with light to medium gray color and razor sharp detail.
$279.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1914-D Buffalo Nickel XF45 PCGS
Item #107907
1914-D Buffalo Nickel XF45 PCGS
A scarce, early date with attractive golden gray color and a sharp strike including a bold horn. There is a little spot in the field below the bison mentioned for accuracy
$229.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1915 Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC
Item #109809
  1915 Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC
Vivid gold toning with gorgeous luster, a bold strike and excellent eye appeal
$295.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1915-D Buffalo Nickel AU55 NGC
Item #109383
  1915-D Buffalo Nickel AU55 NGC
A better date with very original coin and even, dark gray toning giving it more of an XF look at first glance
$135.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1915-S Buffalo Nickel XF45 PCGS CAC
Item #108934
 
  1915-S Buffalo Nickel XF45 PCGS CAC
A scarce, early date with a sharp strike including a razor sharp horn and please, original gray surfaces. Comes complete with a green CAC sticker!
$325.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1916-D Buffalo Nickel MS63 PCGS
Item #110334
  1916-D Buffalo Nickel MS63 PCGS
Lovely golden toned luster over nearly mark free surfaces. Coin is boldly struck including a split tail on the bison!
$239.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1916-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Item #110208
 
  1916-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Lovely even gold toned luster with a sharp strike including a split tail on the bison. A scarce early date that is rare in this high grade!
$435.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1916-S Buffalo Nickel AU Detail PCGS
Item #108857
  1916-S Buffalo Nickel AU Detail PCGS
"AU Detail - Cleaned" While technically cleaned long ago, coin does not look cleaned and has medium gray color with a problem free look. Overall the coin looks more XF as there is no luster apparent
$76.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1917 Buffalo Nickel MS63 ANACS
Item #107111
1917 Buffalo Nickel MS63 ANACS
Beautiful lustrous gold toning on both sides. The centers are a bit weakly struck, though coin has a partial split in the tail and excellent eye appeal!
$95.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1917 Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Item #108431
1917 Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
An early date with beautiful gold toned luster and a bold strike including a split tail!
$185.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1917 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #108707
 
1917 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Magnificent eye appeal with beautiful, even gold toning over mark-free, boldly struck surfaces! Tough to find this nice!
$435.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1917-D Buffalo Nickel AU58 NGC
Item #109558
  1917-D Buffalo Nickel AU58 NGC
A scarce, early date that is very deeply toned in shades of dark, rustic gold and brown on both sides
$285.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1918-D Buffalo Nickel AU Details PCGS
Item #107383
1918-D Buffalo Nickel AU Details PCGS
"AU Detail Environmental Damage" Razor sharp detail with attractive light gray color. Looks problem free with casual inspection, though with magnification the coin exhibits even micro-porosity. A big discount on this scarce date that lists for $240 in the Greysheet!
$179.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1919 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #110508
 
  1919 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Beautiful, even champagne gold toned luster with a razor sharp strike and nice eye appeal! A tough date in MS65!
$385.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1919-D Buffalo Nickel F15 NGC
Item #101608
1919-D Buffalo Nickel F15 NGC
Light gray color with a full date and over 1/2 of the horn visible. There is a little dark streak between the bison's legs
$72.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1919-D Buffalo Nickel VF35 PCGS
Item #109185
  1919-D Buffalo Nickel VF35 PCGS
A scarcer, early date with pleasing light gray surfaces and a bold horn
$175.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1920 Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS CAC
Item #109031
  1920 Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS CAC
Beautiful luster with even light gold toning on the obverse with a couple toning bands on the reverse. A scarcer, early date with a sharp strike and nice eye appeal. Comes complete with a green CAC sticker!
$225.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1920-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC
Item #110536
  1920-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC
Pleasing light gray color with the typical weak strike on the reverse. The horn is about 90% full. Greysheet is $150 in XF!
$95.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1921-S Buffalo Nickel G4
Item #110509
  1921-S Buffalo Nickel G4
Handsome light gray color with a slightly weak, yet fully readable date
$39.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1921-S Buffalo Nickel VF Details NGC
Item #87677
1921-S Buffalo Nickel VF Details NGC
'VF Details, Improperly Cleaned'. Sharply struck obverse, with typical softness on the reverse showing a little over 1/2 horn. Has a very original look, although when examined closely there are traces of a very old cleaning. VF20 Greysheet bid is $235!
$165.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1921-S Buffalo Nickel VG8 NGC
Item #94454
  1921-S Buffalo Nickel VG8 NGC
Full date with a slightly soft '19'. There is a small mint made lamination on the bison and no problems! Scarce date!
$75.00 $65.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1924-D Buffalo Nickel VF35 PCGS Gold Shield
Item #109209
  1924-D Buffalo Nickel VF35 PCGS Gold Shield
Pleasing lighter gray color with a hint of gold toning on the obverse. A scarcer date with a full horn and two little spots in the right obverse field mentioned for accuracy
$110.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1924-D Buffalo Nickel XF45 PCGS
Item #109334
  1924-D Buffalo Nickel XF45 PCGS
A scarcer date with lovely original gray color and nice surfaces. This date is notorious for being softly struck, and this one is a bit soft on the reverse, though still has a full horn!
$199.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF20 Details ANACS
Item #109058
  1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF20 Details ANACS
"VF20 Details - Scratched" Handsome light gray color with about 2/3 of the horn visible. This year rarely shows a full horn in VF, as it is notoriously softly struck. There is a thin scratch on the obverse that is easy to miss, which cuts the price to less than half! Greysheet is $260 in VF20!
$105.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF20 NGC
Item #89334
1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF20 NGC
Full clear date and about 75% of the horn shows. Gray surfaces with a slight bit of shine on the obverse. This date is typically soft in the head area and the horn normally is not full due to strike.
$265.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF20 PCGS
Item #99786
1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF20 PCGS
This scarce date Buffalo is notorious for being weakly struck. Even high grade examples often come without a full horn. This pleasing example has nearly a full horn, with about 3/4 of it full, and has nice color and surfaces. Greysheet bid is $260!
$235.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1924-S Buffalo Nickel XF45 NGC
Item #110385
 
  1924-S Buffalo Nickel XF45 NGC
Handsome light gray color with nice eye appeal and a full horn. This date is notorious for having a weakly struck horn, though this one shows a full horn, though the tip is not clear. A very scarce date that jumps to $1,450 in AU50!
$949.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1925-S Buffalo Nickel VF30 PCGS
Item #110035
  1925-S Buffalo Nickel VF30 PCGS
Pleasing original surfaces with 95% full horn and no problems other than a little spot on the bison's back mentioned for accuracy
$95.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1926-S Buffalo Nickel F15 NGC
Item #91346
  1926-S Buffalo Nickel F15 NGC
Nice light gray original problem free surfaces. The reverse is always weak from strike. This one shows at least half the horn, with the rest of the detail sharper. the date is full. Greysheet is $145 in VF20!
$85.00 $72.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF30 PCGS CAC
Item #108254
1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF30 PCGS CAC
Lovely even gray color with a bold date and 95% full horn. A scarce date with a Greysheet price of $650 in XF40. Comes complete with a green CAC sticker of approval!
$310.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1927 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS Gold Shield
Item #108884
  1927 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS Gold Shield
A real beauty with gorgeous, vivid gold toning on the obverse with a hint of pale sea green on the right rim. Reverse has lustrous sunset gold toning with a touch of magenta behind the bison. Excellent eye appeal!
$225.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1928 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #109583
  1928 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
A boldly struck coin with gorgeous, vivid luster and very light, even gold toning. Excellent eye appeal!
$225.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1928-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Item #110359
  1928-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Gorgeous lustrous gold toning with a hint of silver/blue overlaying the surfaces. Coin is boldly struck with beautiful eye appeal!
$159.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1930-S Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Item #109707
  1930-S Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Boldly struck with attractive, original gold toned luster
$185.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1930-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #109858
  1930-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Beautiful eye appeal with nice luster and pretty gold toning on both sides. A scarce date in MS65 and above!
$335.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1931-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS Gold Shield
Item #110386
  1931-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS Gold Shield
A gorgeous example of this scarcer date with even gold toned luster and a very subtle trace of pastel rainbow in the right obverse field when examined under light!
$235.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1931-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS Secure Shield
Item #108181
 
1931-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS Secure Shield
An absolute dazzler with vivid luster and gorgeous, colorful sunset gold toning on both sides. This scarcer date is sharply struck and has amazing eye appeal!
$279.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1931-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS Secure Shield
Item #107458
1931-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS Secure Shield
This scarce date Buffalo has vibrant luster with touches of attractive gold toning on both sides. Comes in the PCGS Secure Shield holder!
$259.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1934 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #108737
1934 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Vibrant luster with a white obverse and light, even gold toning on the reverse. Greysheet is $425 one point higher!
$185.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1934-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 NGC
Item #92236
  1934-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 NGC
Nice brilliant lustre on this better date for excellent eye appeal
$179.00 $165.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1935 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #108910
  1935 Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Beautiful vibrant luster with even light gold toning
$105.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Item #110060
  1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Nice luster with beautiful gold and light silver toning on the obverse with a subtle hint of very light magenta. Reverse is lustrous with light silver toning and a touch of subtle color
$115.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Item #110086
  1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Beautiful golden toned luster
$110.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Item #105281
1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS
Full toning in various shades of gold and silver with a hint of magenta on the obverse!
$115.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC
Item #110209
  1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC
Gorgeous, vibrant sunset gold toning with beautiful eye appeal! A scarce date in this high grade!
$259.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #109132
  1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Beautiful luster with light gold toning and very subtle hints of iridescent color at the top of the reverse
$275.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1935-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #107484
1935-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Boldly struck with virtually flawless surfaces! Obverse is white while reverse has beautiful, even gold toning
$179.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1935-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Item #108506
1935-S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS
Beautiful eye appeal with impressive luster and even gold toning
$165.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1936-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS CAC
Item #110133
  1936-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS CAC
Sharply struck with beautiful gold toned luster. Comes with a green CAC sticker of approval!
$120.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1936-S Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS
Item #108607
1936-S Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS
Absolutely beautiful, even gold toned luster on both sides. A tough date in MS66!
$175.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1936-S Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS Gold Shield
Item #109609
  1936-S Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS Gold Shield
A boldly struck example with exceptional luster and eye-catching even, light gold toning
$195.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1937 Buffalo Nickel MS67 PCGS
Item #106586
1937 Buffalo Nickel MS67 PCGS
Breathtaking, vibrant luster with boldly struck, mark free surfaces! This date is very scarce in this high grade!
$259.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1937-D 3 Leg Buffalo MS62 NGC
Item #110360
 
  1937-D 3 Leg Buffalo MS62 NGC
Beautiful golden gray luster with nice eye appeal and minimal marks for the grade. A lovely example of this legendary key date and one that we rarely able to offer in minstate condition!
$2,295.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1937-D 3 Leg Buffalo Nickel F15 PCGS
Item #110410
 
  1937-D 3 Leg Buffalo Nickel F15 PCGS
Lovely original gray surfaces with about 1/2 horn showing. A nice, circulated example of this very popular key date!
$459.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1937-D 3 Leg Buffalo XF Details NGC
Item #110260
 
  1937-D 3 Leg Buffalo XF Details NGC
"XF Details - Damaged" Lovely golden gray color with a bold horn. There are two deeper nicks in the center of the obverse and a thin scratch extending from the eye to the field. A big discount and a great buy on this legendary three leg buffalo!
$349.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1938-D/D Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS
Item #108835
  1938-D/D Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS
Beautiful vivid gold toning and breathtaking luster on this popular variety!
$95.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC
Item #108556
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC
Superb luster with beautiful, even gold toning
$190.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC
Item #107508
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC
Absolutely beautiful luster with even, sunset gold toning on both sides! FS-513
$195.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC
Item #107534
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC
Gorgeous luster with beautiful, vivid gold toning! A scarce variety in this high grade! FS-513
$175.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC
Item #109759
  1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC
Eye-catching, rich gold toned luster so vivid that it almost looks like it has been gold plated! This is the scarce D/S variety, which is noted on the holder. The holder has a chip in the upper left corner, and the coin is rotated in the holder
$195.00


Availability: 1 in stock
1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC FS-513
Item #108858
  1938-D/S Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC FS-513
Absolutely beautiful luster with vivid, even champagne gold toning and excellent eye appeal!
$189.00


Availability: 1 in stock
Wholesale 1925 Buffalo Nickel Roll
Item #96106
Wholesale 1925 Buffalo Nickel Roll
A solid date roll of this better date. A quality roll with nearly every coin showing a four digit date. There are a few G4 coins, but most are VG8 or F12. This was purchased by the last owner as a 'F12 Roll'. A great buy, and excellent to sell individually for a profit.
$79.00


Availability: 1 in stock
Page 1 of 1
 

  

SHOPPING CART

Your cart is currently empty

Subtotal:   $0.00

LOGIN

Username / Email:
Password:
 
 

JOIN OUR E-LIST!

RESOURCE CENTER

LAYAWAY CENTER

DAILY DEAL!

ADVERTISEMENT


ORDERING HELP | ORDER FORM | ABOUT US | CONTACT US

Bullion Spot Prices